No results found

MyFitnessPal vs Cronometer vs Eat This Much

divider

Which food tracker wins, and why “winning” depends on the question.

MyFitnessPal vs Cronometer vs Eat This Much

Three apps. Three different philosophies. One question that most comparison articles get wrong before they start.

Almost every “MyFitnessPal vs Cronometer” guide on the internet asks the same thing: which one is the better tracker? The framing assumes that tracking is the goal. We spent six weeks testing all three apps in real use, and the framing turns out to be backwards. Tracking is not the goal. The goal is whatever the user is trying to change, which is usually eating better, hitting a body composition target, managing a health condition, or sustaining a habit past week six. Tracking is one possible means to those ends. It is not the only one.

That matters because the three apps in this comparison are not actually competing for the same job. MyFitnessPal and Cronometer are pure food trackers, and they compete head-to-head on database breadth, accuracy, and user experience. Eat This Much is a meal planner with tracking attached. It solves the decision problem (what to eat) and treats logging as a byproduct.

So the comparison rounds in this guide score all three apps on the seven things that actually matter, but we end up with two parallel verdicts. If the question is “which app is the best food tracker?”, the winner is Cronometer. If the question is “which app will most help me sustainably change what I eat?”, the winner is Eat This Much. The second question is the one most people are actually trying to answer, even when they think they are asking the first.

The contenders

Before the rounds, the headline differences:

Profile

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

Category

Food tracker

Food tracker

Meal planner + tracker

Launched

2005

2011

2011

Active users

200M+

8M+

6M+

Food entries

14M+ (user-submitted)

1.2M (curated)

Recipe-driven

Premium price

$19.99 mo / $79.99 yr

$9.99 mo / $54.95 yr

$5 mo annual / $60 yr

Free tier

Limited (no barcode)

Genuinely useful

Daily plans only

How we tested

All three apps were tested over a six-week period on iOS and Android, with a test user logging an identical 127-entry food list across all three platforms to measure speed, accuracy, and friction. Pricing and feature data was confirmed inside each app at the time of writing. Database accuracy claims draw on independent validation studies published in 2026 (notably the DAI Six-App Validation Study, which measured MyFitnessPal at ±18% MAPE, Cronometer at ±5.2%, and similar precision benchmarks from Calorie App Directory).

Each round below scores the three apps out of 10 on a single dimension. The round winner gets called out. At the end, the scores are totalled, but the totals are less interesting than which app wins which rounds, because no single user cares about every dimension equally.

Disclosure: this guide takes a clear position on the overall winner. Where competitor articles tend to hedge, we land on a recommendation because the analysis genuinely supports it. The reasoning is laid out in each round, and the dissenting case (where Cronometer or MyFitnessPal beats Eat This Much) is given fair weight.

The head-to-head rounds

Seven rounds, each scoring the three apps on a single dimension. The dimension itself matters more than the score.

Round 1: Database breadth

How many foods can the app recognise, and how well does it handle the long tail of branded products, restaurant chains, and obscure regional items.

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

10/10

7/10

6/10

MyFitnessPal

Over 14 million food entries makes MyFitnessPal’s database the largest in the industry, by a wide margin. Whatever the food is (a regional sauce brand, a discontinued energy bar, a restaurant menu item from 2014), someone has already logged it. For users who travel a lot, eat at chain restaurants, or buy a lot of packaged goods, database breadth genuinely matters.

Cronometer

1.2 million entries sounds smaller until the words “curated” are added. Cronometer’s database is built on the USDA National Nutrient Database and NCCDB (Nutrition Coordinating Center) data, with staff verification on entries. Coverage is excellent for whole foods and good for major brands, but weaker for restaurant chains and obscure packaged products. For users buying mostly fresh ingredients and cooking at home, this is rarely a problem.

Eat This Much

Eat This Much’s database is recipe-driven rather than entry-driven, which makes the comparison awkward. The food database underlying its recipes is large enough that meal planning works well, and barcode tracking covers most common products. But for users who specifically want to log a Five Guys cheeseburger ordered last Tuesday, MyFitnessPal will find it faster.

Round winner: MyFitnessPal. On raw database breadth, MyFitnessPal is the clear winner. The 14 million entries dwarf both competitors. This is the round MyFitnessPal absolutely wins, and for users who genuinely need long-tail database coverage, it is enough to swing the whole comparison.

Round 2: Data accuracy

How accurate are the calorie and macro numbers the database returns. This is where database size and database quality stop being the same thing.

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

4/10

10/10

8/10

MyFitnessPal

Database breadth comes at a cost. MyFitnessPal’s 14 million entries are mostly user-submitted, which means duplicates, eyeballed quantities, and outright incorrect entries are common. The DAI Six-App Validation Study (March 2026) measured MyFitnessPal’s typical accuracy at ±18% MAPE (mean absolute percentage error) on a controlled food set. For users who do not double-check entries, the daily calorie total can be off by several hundred calories without anyone noticing.

Cronometer

Cronometer’s data comes from USDA, NCCDB, and other peer-reviewed nutritional databases. Staff verify entries before they enter the searchable database. The same DAI study measured Cronometer’s accuracy at ±5.2% MAPE, the tightest of any consumer tracker tested. For users tracking for genuine health reasons (medical nutrition therapy, cardiovascular risk management, athletic performance), the accuracy gap actually changes outcomes.

Eat This Much

Eat This Much pulls nutrition data into its recipes from a curated underlying database, and the macro figures inside the auto-generated meal plans hold up well in spot-checking. The app is not optimised for ad-hoc logging of random foods, so the accuracy comparison is not quite like-for-like, but the data quality on what it tracks is closer to Cronometer than to MyFitnessPal.

Round winner: Cronometer. For users who care about whether the numbers on the screen reflect what they actually ate, Cronometer wins this round decisively. The 13-point accuracy gap between Cronometer and MyFitnessPal is the single most important data point in this entire comparison.

Round 3: Speed of logging

How long does it take to log a meal. This sounds trivial. It is not. The biggest predictor of whether a tracking app gets used in week 6 is how much friction logging adds in week 1.

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

7/10

6/10

9/10

MyFitnessPal

When the barcode scanner works and the food is in the database, MyFitnessPal is fast. The autocomplete is responsive, recent foods are pinned, and copy-from-yesterday works well. The catch in 2026: the barcode scanner sits behind the Premium paywall on the free tier. For free users, logging requires manual search, which slows the whole workflow down noticeably.

Cronometer

Cronometer is fast once users are used to it, but the interface is denser than MyFitnessPal and the learning curve is steeper. The barcode scanner is free, recent foods are pinned, and recipe import from URLs works well. New users typically take a week longer to hit comfortable logging speed than they would on MyFitnessPal. By week 6, the gap closes.

Eat This Much

Eat This Much wins this round by sidestepping the question. When the meal plan generates the day’s meals in advance, the user does not log retroactively. The day’s food is already in the planner. Eating something that matches the plan requires zero additional logging effort. Eating something off-plan requires a quick swap or manual entry. The net friction across a full week is meaningfully lower than either dedicated tracker.

Round winner: Eat This Much. The fastest logging is the logging that does not have to happen. By front-loading meal decisions into a generated plan, Eat This Much removes most of the daily logging friction that causes users to abandon trackers. This is a non-obvious win that does not show up in feature comparisons.

Round 4: User experience and interface

How pleasant is the daily experience. This rolls together design quality, ad volume, upgrade pressure, and how the app feels after a month of consistent use.

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

5/10

7/10

9/10

MyFitnessPal

MyFitnessPal’s interface is polished on the surface and increasingly aggressive underneath. The free tier in 2026 is heavily ad-supported, with video ads, banner ads, and frequent Premium upgrade prompts. The Verge described the company’s shift toward paywalling features as “an egregious disservice to users.” The app still works, but the daily experience has noticeably degraded over the past two years.

Cronometer

Cronometer’s interface is dense, data-forward, and almost ad-free even on the free tier. New users find the nutrient grid overwhelming for the first few days. After that, most users report appreciating how much information is visible at a glance. The aesthetic leans clinical rather than consumer-friendly, but the daily experience is cleaner and less manipulative than MyFitnessPal’s.

Eat This Much

Eat This Much’s interface is the most polished of the three for what it does. The weekly meal plan view is clear, individual meals can be swapped with a single tap, and the grocery list integrates cleanly. There are no ads on either the free or Premium tier. Upgrade prompts exist but are restrained. The daily experience is closer to a modern consumer app than either dedicated tracker.

Round winner: Eat This Much. The user experience round goes to Eat This Much by a notable margin. No ads on either tier, restrained upgrade prompts, and a daily experience that genuinely feels good to open. Cronometer comes second, with MyFitnessPal a distant third on user experience specifically.

Round 5: Health and micronutrient depth

How well does the app handle the nutrients that matter for actual health outcomes: fibre, omega-3, sodium, saturated fat, vitamin D, iron, magnesium. This is the round that matters most for users with a real health reason for tracking.

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

4/10

10/10

7/10

MyFitnessPal

MyFitnessPal tracks 14 nutrients by default. Detailed micronutrient tracking sits behind Premium and is shallower than Cronometer even there. For users tracking only calories and macros, this is enough. For users managing cardiovascular risk, anaemia, vitamin D deficiency, or specific dietary patterns, MyFitnessPal’s nutrient panel is too thin to be useful.

Cronometer

Cronometer tracks 80+ vitamins and minerals on the free plan, with omega-3 split into EPA and DHA for users targeting cardiovascular benefits specifically. Sodium, saturated fat, and fibre all appear prominently on the daily view. Reports can be exported to PDF and shared with healthcare providers. This is the round Cronometer was built for.

Eat This Much

Eat This Much tracks the standard macro and micronutrient breakdown for its planned meals, which is enough for most users following a generally healthy diet. The nutrient panel is less detailed than Cronometer’s, and the app is not the right tool for users managing a specific medical condition where micronutrient precision matters.

Round winner: Cronometer. Cronometer wins this round decisively. For users with a real health reason to track (cardiovascular risk, deficiency management, athletic performance), Cronometer’s micronutrient depth is the strongest single argument in its favour. This is where the app earns its devoted following.

Round 6: Pricing and value

What does each app actually cost, and what does that buy. Prices have shifted significantly across all three apps in the past two years.

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

4/10

8/10

10/10

MyFitnessPal

MyFitnessPal Premium is $19.99 per month or $79.99 per year. A higher Premium+ tier at $99.99 per year adds meal planning features. The free tier is increasingly limited (no barcode scanner, no macro grams, heavy ads). For users wanting basic functionality, the realistic cost is the Premium tier. The pricing is the highest of the three apps in this comparison and the value-for-money has declined visibly since the 2020 sale to Francisco Partners.

Cronometer

Cronometer Gold is $9.99 per month or $54.95 per year. The free tier is genuinely useful, including barcode scanning, full micronutrient tracking, and ad-light experience. Most users can stay on the free tier indefinitely. For those who upgrade, Gold adds fasting timer, custom charts, food suggestions, and priority support. Pricing has held steady for several years.

Eat This Much

Eat This Much Premium is $5 per month on the annual plan or $15 monthly. That delivers automated weekly meal planning, real grocery list automation, Instacart and Amazon Fresh integration, leftovers logic, and PDF export. For the equivalent of one coffee per month, the value is the strongest in this comparison by a wide margin. The free tier covers daily plans, custom recipes, and barcode tracking.

Round winner: Eat This Much. At $5 per month annual, Eat This Much delivers meal planning, automated grocery lists, and basic tracking for a quarter of MyFitnessPal’s price. Even allowing for the different categories, the value proposition is the strongest of the three. Cronometer earns a strong second on free-tier value.

Round 7: Sustained behaviour change

The most important round, and the one most comparison articles skip. Does the app actually help users change what they eat over months, not weeks. This is the only metric that matters for outcomes.

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

4/10

6/10

10/10

MyFitnessPal

MyFitnessPal is a logging tool, not a behaviour change tool. It tells users what they ate. It does not tell them what to eat next. Research on tracking apps consistently shows that logging alone produces short-term awareness but weak long-term behaviour change. Most users who download MyFitnessPal abandon it within 90 days. For users who already know what they should be eating and just need to verify, the tool works. For users still figuring out what to eat, MyFitnessPal places the entire cognitive burden on them.

Cronometer

Cronometer’s precision and depth produce real awareness, particularly for users with a specific health goal. Users tracking for medical reasons (cardiovascular risk, diabetes, deficiencies) tend to stick with Cronometer longer than they stick with MyFitnessPal, because the data is actionable. For general weight loss users, retention is better than MyFitnessPal but still falls short of meal-planning apps, because the workflow remains reactive rather than prescriptive.

Eat This Much

Eat This Much inverts the workflow. Instead of logging meals after eating, users follow a generated plan. Adherence becomes default rather than effortful. The grocery list pushes the plan into actual shopping behaviour. Real-world outcomes from users following the plan consistently for 12+ weeks show meaningful weight loss and improved adherence to dietary patterns like Mediterranean and lower-carb. The cognitive burden is shifted from the user (“what should I eat?”) to the app (“here is what you are eating”).

Round winner: Eat This Much. This is the round that actually matters most, and Eat This Much wins it by a wide margin. Tracking is a means, not an end. Sustained change comes from removing decisions, not adding data. For most users, the meal-planning-first approach beats the tracking-first approach on long-term outcomes.

Total scores

Seven rounds, scored out of 10 each, totalling 70.

MyFitnessPal

Cronometer

Eat This Much

38/70

54/70

59/70

Eat This Much wins on total points, with Cronometer a strong second and MyFitnessPal a distant third. But totals are the least interesting part of the analysis. The more important question is which rounds matter most for which user.

Which one wins for which user

The total scores hide the more useful answer, which is that each app wins for a specific kind of user. Picking the right tool means matching the strengths to the problem worth solving.

Pick MyFitnessPal if...

The user already has a stable diet they want to log accurately, the food is mostly packaged goods or chain restaurants where database breadth matters, and they already pay for Premium and have years of historical data they do not want to migrate. MyFitnessPal is also the right pick if accuracy is genuinely not a top priority (the user is logging for awareness rather than precision, and ±18% is acceptable). For most other users, the value proposition is hard to defend against the alternatives.

Pick Cronometer if...

The user has a specific health reason to track (cardiovascular risk, diabetes, deficiency management, athletic performance), micronutrient depth matters, data accuracy is non-negotiable, and the user is willing to climb a slightly steeper learning curve in week 1 in exchange for a cleaner, faster experience by week 6. Cronometer is also the right pick for users who pair tracking with regular conversations with a dietitian, since the export-to-PDF feature produces clinic-ready data.

Pick Eat This Much if...

The user wants the underlying outcome (sustainable change in what they eat) more than the underlying mechanism (tracking what they ate). The biggest blocker is deciding what to eat each day, the household includes multiple people whose preferences need to be coordinated, the kitchen would benefit from automated grocery list generation, and price-to-value matters. This is most users in 2026, even when they search for “best food tracker” first.

The verdict, in one sentence

Cronometer wins the food tracker comparison. Eat This Much wins the broader question that most people are actually asking when they search for “best food tracker” in the first place. MyFitnessPal wins on database breadth and brand recognition, but loses on every other dimension that matters.

For the user who knows exactly what they want (precision tracking, no meal planning, willing to do the daily logging work), Cronometer is the right pick. For everyone else, which is most readers of this guide, Eat This Much solves the underlying problem more directly. The user who picks Eat This Much will spend less time logging, less time deciding what to cook, and more time actually eating better. That is the outcome the search query was looking for, even when the search terms suggested otherwise.

RECOMMENDED

hunter
Wed 18 Nov 2026

ADVERTORIAL Hunting after dark presents a very different set of challenges from daytime fieldcraft. Familiar ground changes character once the light fades: hedgerows become solid black barriers, dips in

office
Wed 18 Nov 2026

ADVERTORIAL The way a workplace looks and sounds has a real effect on the people inside it. Since the shift to hybrid working, many employers have found that staff need a good reason to come into the office.

eyes
Wed 18 Nov 2026

ADVERTORIAL A patient presents with thin, crepey, dull periorbital skin and mild hollowing. They want something done under the eyes, but they have seen the blue-grey cast tear trough filler can leave, on

storage
Wed 18 Nov 2026

ADVERTORIAL Every great business has to begin somewhere, and more often than not it’s somewhere unglamorous. A spare room. A kitchen table. A garage with a leaky roof and a car that never quite fits.